When Serial first launched, it changed how people consumed audio storytelling. Instead of episodic crime summaries, listeners were invited into a season-long investigation, complete with evolving evidence, uncertainty, and moral complexity. That format didn’t just entertain, it trained audiences to think critically and stay engaged across multiple episodes.
Since then, a new generation of podcasts has followed Serial’s blueprint: deep reporting, narrative tension, and real-world impact. This guide curates the best podcasts like Serial for 2026 shows that value accuracy over shock, context over speed, and human consequences over sensationalism. Every pick below rewards attentive listening and delivers the kind of storytelling that makes you queue “next episode” without hesitation.
How We Selected These Podcasts (Why It Matters)
Not every true crime podcast qualifies as “Serial-like.” For this list, we focused on shows that demonstrate:
Season-long or case-driven narratives
Original reporting or investigative depth
Clear sourcing and ethical storytelling
Measured pacing that builds understanding
Meaningful insight into justice, systems, or human behavior
These criteria matter because they separate journalism-driven audio from entertainment-only crime content. The podcasts below don’t just tell stories they add clarity, surface overlooked facts, or challenge official narratives
Investigative & True Crime Podcasts (Most Similar to Serial)
1. Criminal
Focus: Human-centered crime stories
Best for: Listeners who value nuance over shock
Why it’s different: Hosted by Phoebe Judge, Criminal examines why people commit crimes, not just what happened.
Each episode stands alone, yet the emotional throughline makes it ideal for reflective listening.
Criminal is a staple in the mystery podcast world, sharing strange, insightful stories of people who’ve done wrong or been wronged. Hosted by the calm and captivating Phoebe Judge, the show stands out for its human-centered storytelling and unexpected twists. It’s smartly written and beautifully produced, perfect for those who like their mysteries reflective, thoughtful, and deeply human.
Here are a few reasons why Criminal is a must-listen:
Compelling Narratives: Each episode presents a unique case, ranging from petty crimes to elaborate schemes.
Excellent Production Quality: The sound design and editing are top-notch, creating an immersive listening experience.
Thought-Provoking Themes: The podcast explores complex issues of morality, justice, and the human condition.
Criminal isn’t just about the crime itself; it’s about the people involved and the circumstances that led them there. It offers a nuanced perspective on true crime, making it a standout in the genre.
Listen Now
2. Up And Vanished
Focus: Cold cases and real-time investigations
Best for: Fans of unfolding discoveries
Why it’s different: The Tara Grinstead case showed how podcast journalism can influence real-world outcomes.
Listeners follow the investigation as evidence evolves very much in the Serial tradition.
Up and Vanished is an investigative podcast that takes a deep look into cold cases. The first season really took off when it covered the disappearance of Tara Grinstead, a beauty queen from Georgia who went missing back in 2005. Payne Lindsey, the host, does a great job of uncovering new information, which actually helped move the case forward.
Some episodes you should check out are “The Black Truck” and “The Case Breaks,” because that’s where things really start to happen. It’s like you’re right there with them, trying to figure out what happened. If you like feeling like you’re part of the investigation from start to finish, this one’s for you.
It’s pretty amazing how a podcast can actually have a real-world impact on a case. It makes you wonder how many other cold cases could be solved if they got the same kind of attention.
Listen Now
3. In the Dark
Focus: Systemic failures in the justice system
Best for: Those who want accountability-driven reporting
Why it’s different: Multi-year investigations that uncover flaws others missed.
This is investigative journalism first, podcast second.
In The Dark is a podcast that really digs deep. It’s not just about telling a story; it’s about examining the justice system itself. Season 1 focuses on the abduction of Jacob Wetterling, a case that went unsolved for 27 years. Season 2 investigates Curtis Flowers, a man tried six times for the same crime.
What sets this podcast apart is its investigative journalism. It doesn’t just recount events; it uncovers new information and challenges the official narrative. It makes you question everything you thought you knew about these cases.
Listen Now
4. Casefile
Focus: Detailed crime reconstruction
Best for: Listeners who prefer facts over commentary
Why it’s different: Anonymous narration and meticulous timelines remove bias and dramatization.
Casefile is an Australian true crime podcast known for its straightforward approach and meticulous attention to detail. The anonymous narrator’s calm, emotionless voice adds an unsettling dimension to the already chilling cases. This podcast delves into both solved and unsolved crimes from around the globe.
It’s perfect for listeners who appreciate thorough research, detailed timelines, and criminal psychology without any sensationalism or unnecessary additions. If you’re looking for more content after listening to Casefile, consider checking out some of the best podcasts for women for a different perspective.
Listen Now
5. Someone Knows Something
Focus: Cold cases and unresolved disappearances
Best for: Long-form listeners who value persistence
Why it’s different: Host David Ridgen actively pursues new leads, not just retells events.
Someone Knows Something is a podcast hosted by David Ridgen, and it really digs into cold cases. Each season focuses on a different unsolved mystery, and the goal is always to find new leads and, hopefully, bring some resolution to the families involved. It’s not just about telling a story; it’s about actively trying to uncover the truth.
What I appreciate about this podcast is its commitment to the investigation. It’s not just rehashing old news; it’s about finding new information and giving a voice to those who have been unheard for too long.
It’s a pretty compelling listen, especially if you’re into true crime with a purpose. The host really gets involved, and you can tell he cares about the cases he covers. If you are interested in true crime podcast, this is a good one to check out.
Listen Now
Listen to: Best True Crime Podcasts
Justice, Society & Ethical Crime Reporting
6. Missing & Murdered
Focus: Crimes against Indigenous women
Best for: Social justice–minded listeners
Why it’s different: Hosted by Connie Walker, it centers historical and systemic context often ignored elsewhere.
Missing & Murdered is a podcast that really digs into the under-reported crimes against Indigenous women and girls in Canada. Hosted by Connie Walker, an Indigenous journalist, the podcast offers a unique perspective on these cases. It’s not just about the crimes themselves, but also the historical and systemic issues that contribute to them.
One of the most powerful seasons is “Finding Cleo,” which follows the search for Cleo Semaganis Nicotine, a Cree girl taken by child services in the 1970s. The episodes reveal layers of trauma and resilience, making it a vital and emotional listen. The host, Ian, from the podcast Uncover: Calls From A Killer doesn’t rely on research, but Connie Walker does.
This podcast doesn’t shy away from the hard truths, and it’s a reminder of the ongoing injustices faced by Indigenous communities. It’s a must-listen for anyone interested in true crime and social justice.
Listen Now
7. Anatomy of Murder
Focus: Legal and investigative processes
Best for: Listeners curious about how cases are built
Why it’s different: Hosted by a former prosecutor and detective, offering professional insight.
Anatomy of Murder takes a different approach to true crime. Hosted by a former prosecutor and a retired detective, the podcast offers unique insights into the criminal justice system. They dissect cases, providing listeners with an understanding of how investigations unfold and trials proceed. It’s less about the sensationalism and more about the process.
Each episode typically focuses on a single case, exploring the evidence, the legal strategies, and the ultimate outcome. The hosts bring a professional perspective, offering informed opinions and analysis. It’s a great listen for anyone interested in the inner workings of the legal system and how cases are built from the ground up. One episode that stands out is their episode on the Don Vaughn murder case.
The hosts’ backgrounds provide a level of expertise that’s hard to find elsewhere. They don’t just tell the story; they explain the legal and investigative aspects, making it educational as well as gripping.
Listen Now
8. The Vanished
Focus: Lesser-known missing persons cases
Best for: Empathetic, family-centered storytelling
Why it’s different: Prioritizes interviews with families and investigators over speculation.
The Vanished podcast focuses on missing persons cases that often don’t get much attention. Marissa Jones hosts, and she’s really good at talking to families, law enforcement, and other experts to get all the details. It’s a tough listen, but it’s important.
Some episodes, like the ones about “Brandon Lawson” and “Phoenix Coldon,” are especially sad because they leave you with so many questions. It really makes you think about how many people are still missing and how each episode could potentially help someone be found.
This podcast is a stark reminder of the unresolved pain and uncertainty that families of missing persons endure. It highlights the importance of continued investigation and the hope that one day, answers will be found.
Listen Now
Listen to: Podcasts That Changed the Justice System
High-Impact Narrative & Cold Case Podcasts
9. Bear Brook
Focus: Cold case solved through genetic genealogy
Best for: Science-meets-crime listeners
Why it’s different: Shows how modern forensics can unlock decades-old mysteries.
Bear Brook is a gripping podcast that unravels a complex cold case involving unidentified bodies found in barrels in Bear Brook State Park, New Hampshire. What makes this podcast stand out is its use of genetic genealogy to identify the victims and the perpetrator.
It’s a wild ride, and here’s why you should listen:
The mystery is super twisty.
The science is actually pretty cool.
The storytelling is top-notch.
This podcast isn’t just about the crime; it’s about the science that helped solve it. It’s a fascinating look at how new technologies are changing the way we investigate old cases. If you are looking for thrilling stories, this is it.
Listen Now
10. Bone Valley
Focus: Miscarriage of justice
Best for: Fans of Serial Season One
Why it’s different: Explores both the wrongly convicted and the true perpetrator with rare balance.
Bone Valley is a podcast that really sticks with you. It’s not just another true crime story; it’s a deep dive into a case of wrongful conviction, focusing on the story of Leo Schofield, who was convicted of murdering his wife Michelle. What makes this podcast stand out is the meticulous investigation led by Gilbert King, a Pulitzer Prize-winning author. He really digs into the details, presenting a compelling narrative that makes you question everything.
The podcast doesn’t just focus on Leo’s plight; it also explores the humanity of the person who actually committed the crime. This approach adds layers of complexity and forces you to consider themes of forgiveness and redemption.
It’s a powerful and emotional listen, and it’s easy to see why so many people consider it one of the best true crime podcasts out there. If you’re looking for something that will keep you hooked and make you think, give Bone Valley a listen.
Listen Now
11. Dirty John
Focus: Psychological manipulation and deception
Best for: Relationship-based crime narratives
Why it’s different: Emphasizes emotional impact over procedural detail.
Dirty John is a podcast that really grabs you. It tells the story of Debra Newell, a successful interior designer, and her whirlwind romance with John Meehan. What starts as a fairy tale quickly turns into a nightmare. The podcast is a masterclass in suspense, revealing John’s dark past and manipulative behavior layer by layer.
It’s one of those stories where you’re constantly yelling at your speakers, wondering how someone could fall for such obvious red flags. But that’s part of what makes it so compelling. You get sucked into Debra’s world, experiencing her confusion, denial, and ultimately, her fear. The podcast does a great job of portraying the psychological manipulation involved, making you question how well you really know the people in your life.
The story is based on real events, which adds another layer of chilling realism. It’s not just a fictional thriller; it’s a true account of deception, betrayal, and survival. It makes you think about the dangers of online dating and the importance of trusting your gut.
Listen Now
Listen to: How Podcasts Influence Public Opinion
Lighter or Hybrid Serial-Style Podcasts
12. Crime Junkie
Focus: Weekly crime cases
Best for: Casual true crime listeners
Why it’s different: Direct, conversational format with consistent release schedule.
Crime Junkie is a podcast that dives headfirst into true crime cases with a straightforward, no-nonsense approach. Hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, the show delivers weekly episodes that cover a wide range of crimes, from missing persons to solved murders. What sets Crime Junkie apart is its conversational style and focus on getting straight to the facts, making it a favorite for listeners who appreciate a direct and engaging narrative.
Crime Junkie has faced some controversy regarding sourcing and attribution, but it remains a popular choice for many true crime enthusiasts. If you’re looking for a podcast that delivers a new case every week with a focus on the details, this might be the one for you. It’s like sitting down with friends to discuss the latest true crime news, but with a structured and informative presentation.
Crime Junkie is a great option if you want a podcast that gets right to the point. The hosts are engaging, and the cases are well-researched, even if there have been some past issues with sourcing. It’s a solid choice for a quick true crime fix.
Listen Now
13. My Favorite Murder
Focus: True crime with humor
Best for: Listeners who want lighter tone
Why it’s different: Blends empathy, comedy, and community-driven storytelling.
If you’re searching for a podcast like serial but with a comedic twist, “My Favorite Murder” might be your next obsession. Hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, this podcast blends true crime storytelling with humor and personal anecdotes. It’s not just about the cases; it’s about the hosts’ chemistry and their ability to make even the darkest topics approachable.
It’s easy to see why it’s considered one of the best podcasts like serial for many listeners. Each episode typically features Karen and Georgia recounting a murder case, sharing their thoughts, and often relating it back to their own lives. This personal touch sets it apart from more straightforward true crime podcasts.
While it might not have the same investigative depth as “Serial,” it offers a different kind of appeal. The hosts’ banter and comedic timing make it a lighter listen, perfect for those who enjoy true crime but need a break from the heavier, more serious tones of other podcasts similar to serial. It’s a unique blend that has garnered a massive following.
The podcast’s success lies in its ability to balance the grim realities of true crime with humor and empathy. It’s a testament to the hosts’ ability to connect with their audience on a personal level, making listeners feel like they’re part of a community.
Listen Now
14. Death of an Artist
Focus: Art world mystery
Best for: Art and culture enthusiasts
Why it’s different: Combines creative industry insight with investigative rigor.
Death Of An Artist is a fascinating podcast that delves into the art world, but with a dark twist. It explores the life and mysterious death of Anna Hotton, a rising star in the New York art scene. The podcast isn’t just about art; it’s a true crime story that keeps you guessing. It’s a great listen for anyone interested in art, mystery, or true crime.
The podcast meticulously examines the evidence, interviews key figures, and presents a compelling narrative that challenges the official conclusions. It’s a deep dive into a world of creativity, ambition, and potential foul play.
Here’s why you should give it a listen:
Intriguing subject matter
Well-researched investigation
Keeps you guessing until the end
Listen Now
15. Dr. Death
Focus: Medical malpractice and trust abuse
Best for: Listeners interested in institutional failure
Why it’s different: Exposes systemic gaps that allow harm by professionals.
Dr. Death is a podcast that explores the chilling reality of medical professionals who inflict harm on their patients. It’s not your typical serial killer story; it’s about people in positions of trust abusing their power. The podcast, often hosted by Laura Beil, delves into cases where doctors, who are supposed to save lives, end up causing immense suffering and even death. It really makes you think about the healthcare system and its vulnerabilities.
One of the most gripping seasons is Miracle Man. It starts with what seems like a perfect love story: a reporter falling for a surgeon making incredible medical breakthroughs. But the story quickly unravels, revealing the devastating consequences of a man obsessed with playing God. It’s a wild ride that shows how easily people can be deceived by charisma and false promises.
The podcast is a sobering reminder that not everyone in a white coat can be trusted. It highlights the importance of patient advocacy and the need for greater transparency in healthcare.
Listen Now
Quick Summary
Closest to Serial: In the Dark, Bone Valley
Best cold cases: Bear Brook, Someone Knows Something
Systemic justice focus: Missing & Murdered, Anatomy of Murder
Lighter tone: My Favorite Murder, Crime Junkie
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes a podcast “like Serial”?
A Serial-style podcast follows a single case or theme over multiple episodes, includes original reporting, and allows uncertainty rather than rushing conclusions.
Are all podcasts like Serial true crime?
No. While most focus on crime, some explore historical events, social justice, or institutional failures using the same investigative format.
Which podcast should I start with after Serial?
In the Dark or Bone Valley are the most natural next steps due to their depth and investigative rigor.
Do these podcasts help solve real cases?
Yes. Shows like Up and Vanished and Someone Knows Something have generated new leads and renewed public attention.
